Welcome to She Sings Cafe, Restaurant and Bar, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Mayville, NY, right on the shores of Chautauqua Lake. Located at 95 W Lake Rd, this delightful establishment offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion, be it a casual breakfast, a romantic dinner, or a fun night out with friends. Hold onto your taste buds, as the culinary creations here promise to take you on a flavorful journey.
My visit to She Sings was nothing short of exceptional. Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the charming decor, which is a perfect blend of elegance and coziness. The warm ambiance invites you to sit back, relax, and savor every moment. The dedication of the staff truly enhances the experience; each team member seems to share a genuine passion for food and hospitality.
Let’s talk about the food—oh, the food! The SHE SINGS® SKILLET is a must-try, featuring perfectly cooked home fries, savory sausage, and melting cheddar cheese, all generously topped with rich country gravy over a fluffy omelette for just US$16.00. The CHICKEN AND WAFFLES also stands out, marrying crispy southern fried chicken with sweet, warm waffles for a delightful balance of flavors, capturing the essence of comfort food.
For a satisfying sweet treat, the SHORT STACK PANCAKES are simply heaven, served warm with fluffy butter and syrup for US$9.00. Patrons rave about the FRENCH TOAST STICKS, which you can customize with strawberries, blueberries, or chocolate chips to please any palate.
The main courses are crafted with just as much love and attention. The "DICK'S HARBOR HOUSE" WILD HADDOCK FISH FRY, priced at US$22.00, is a standout, offering a crispy exterior with tender fish inside, accompanied by house-cut fries and coleslaw that leave you wanting more. Not to mention the GRUYÈRE SMOKED MEATLOAF, which garnered rave reviews for its rich, garlic flavor and perfectly smashed potatoes—a dish you absolutely must not miss.
As I indulged in the delightful offerings, my experience was only heightened by meeting the owner, whose warmth and charm embody the spirit of She Sings. This personal touch resonates throughout, from the visually appealing plates to the thoughtfully curated cocktail and wine menus.
With plenty of space to enjoy your meal, whether inside or on the patio, She Sings Cafe, Restaurant and Bar is more than just a dining destination; it's a place where memories are made. While a few reviews mentioned delays during busy times, the overall feedback about the food and service suggests that it's worth the wait.
If you find yourself in the Mayville area, make sure to stop by She Sings. The combination of outstanding service, exquisite food, and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a place you'll remember and want to return to time and time again.
For reservations or inquiries, reach out to them at +1 716-224-1090 and prepare yourself for a culinary experience worthy of singing about!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
707 North St, Rochester, NY 14605, United States
13 Mechanic St, Norwood, NY 13668, United States
39 W Main St, Cambridge, NY 12816, United States
208-01 Jamaica Ave, Queens Village, NY 11428, United States
37-14 73rd St, Jackson Heights, NY 11372, United States
7 Ground Floor, Kompleks Perniagaan LITC, 05150 Alor Setar, Kedah, Malaysia
2926 13th Ave, Regina, SK S4T 1N7, Canada
112 Ormond Rd, Elwood VIC 3184, Australia
62130-000, Via John Sanford, 199, Meruoca - CE, 62130-000, Brazil
Av. Cesário de Melo, 5743 - Campo Grande, Rio de Janeiro - RJ, 23055-002, Brazil
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Kelley Eichberg
19/10/2025
My husband and I spent the weekend on Chautauqua Lake for our anniversary in July, 2025. We went to She Sings restaurant for dinner, not only was the staff friendly and service outstanding but the food was delicious. We were so impressed that my husband ordered a second dinner and we returned for breakfast the following morning and was equally delicious. Bonus, the owner herself greeted us and personally made us feel welcome. A lovely place we look forward to returning!
Sheri Kamikow
24/09/2025
We made a reservation and we were able to get in at the time we asked for. Our server Alice was pretty fantastic. She cleared the table before we got there. She had to wash the table and then she seated us and had to deal with a ton of other people outside and she did it efficiently and she was super friendly. The food was good. My only complaint is it seemed like the kitchen had a hard Managing the Orders. It took over 60 minutes to get our food, but it was worth the weight. They should have three more people named Alice working in their Restaurant she was the best part of the experience!
Mike Hancey
21/09/2025
First time in and loved it!!! Michelle was fantastic. She suggested the smoked meatloaf or the fish fry. We couldn't decide so we ordered both and shared. Definitely coming back again... real garlic mashed potatoes, and handcut fries. A very welcome surprise!!! Try the cocktails, you'll be glad you did!!
Renee Boyer
09/09/2025
Best food we've had in this area. I got the gluten free fried haddock and it was so good! Crispy breading and fresh haddock. Not at all greasy, cooked perfectly. Coleslaw and fries were good too. Waitress recommended meatloaf so that's what my husband got. He said it was the best meatloaf he'd ever had so I tried a bite. I have to agree! Delicious! If we're ever back this way, we're definitely stopping here!
Kate Drcar
13/08/2025
A Hidden Gem Worth Singing About She Sings is an absolute delight—every dish we tried was incredible, full of flavor and beautifully presented. The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and spotless, with thoughtful touches that make the space feel both elegant and welcoming. One of the highlights of our visit was meeting the owner, who took time to personally greet our group. She is every bit as lovely and genuine as the space she’s created. It’s clear this place was crafted with heart. The cocktail menu is creative and fun, and the wine selection is thoughtfully curated. We appreciated the attention to detail across the board. If we had one piece of feedback, it would be about the background music—not the live performances, which were great—but the playlist playing through the speakers. It leaned a little heavy and somber. Something a bit lighter or more upbeat might enhance the overall mood and match the vibrant energy of the rest of the experience. All in all, a fantastic night. We’ll absolutely be back!
Lisa Goodman
07/08/2025
Loved our server, Alice she was really knowledgeable and friendly! The food was very good. We both have the fish fry which was haddock and we were impressed with it. We also had calamari which was good. My only complaint was that it took a really long time to get the food. They need to get the kitchen situation moving fast faster, but the server made it good for us. We ordered drinks and we had a nice time.!